The Band’s Visit was a short but funny and engaging Israeli film where the plot circulates around a police band trying to find their next show. The beauty of this film comes from the plot being small and a real-life everyday occurrence. The director, Eran Kolirin, does a fantastic job of showing different stories and subplots unravel during the film. These subplots were all very engaging and humorous. When the two guys are at the phone “battling,” was a subplot that was very small and simple, but very funny. Although it was disqualified in the Academy Awards for having too much English, I believe the film does a great job showing two different cultures. The dialogue does not actually say how these two cultures can get along but it infers that although these two cultures may be enemies, they are just the same ordinary people with the same ordinary hopes and dreams. They can actually get along.
Most of the humor throughout the film does not come from the dialogue because there is not a lot of dialogue going on. The body language of the characters and the camera shots Kolirin uses provide the humor of the film. The scene at the roller-skating rink proved to be my favorite scene of the entire film. It was a classic situation of the “ladies man” trying to show the “shy” guy different tactics to get the girl. Although there is very little dialogue on the bench that all three were sitting at, I was laughing out loud through the whole thing. It was something so simple as trying to get a girl but it becomes so comical.
I really enjoyed the ending of the movie. All the subplots come together as everyone falls asleep and wakes up in the morning. Then the next scene shows the band playing at their show and skipping how they actually got to the location. I felt like this was a great way to end it because it shows Tawfiq in his highest element of happiness conducting the orchestra.
Friday, May 21, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The opening scene of the Bands Visit immediately got the audience laughing. Eight policemen from Alexandria Orchestra got off a bus in the middle of the desert. The policemen ranged from attractive, fat, skinny, old and young and instantly all looked lost. Their costumes all matched and made it easy for the audience to tell that they were serious about their profession. At the airport the policemen do not seem very welcomed and have a hard time trying to figure out where to go. This is just a small road bump to a long road ahead for them. One of the best scenes in the film was when the men got their picture taken. It took them a while to finally get situated then a janitor stops in front of them, their picture still got taken. No one would think that would be funny and the director made it hysterical. It was just something about their facial expressions in those baby blue outfits that made it funny. Another funny scene was when a local man kept waiting next to the pay phone. The audience noticed how impatient he was when another person used the phone. Some people are obsessive like that in our society so the audience might be able to relate to that. Towards the middle and end of the film, the audience got attached to the characters.
ReplyDeleteTewfiq was quiet and as the movie went on, I was eager to learn more about him. He got made fun of once but stuck it out and kept going forward. As the film continued, Tewfiq started to open up more. Although his wife and son died, it was easy to see that music brought him happiness. The art of this film was the communication and it happened through pictures. There were a lot of scenes that had no dialogue. The scene of the policemen eating dinner zoomed in on their facial expressions. It was easy to figure out how awkward it must have been because they were just sitting listening to the family have a conversation. Even when the policemen did not talk, the audience could tell what they were thinking, just by the look on their face. Eran Kolirin shows two different cultures and how they are viewed as just,”people.” They may be enemies but the movie showed them helping each other out. At one point during the film the Egyptians and Israelis were singing jazz songs together and having a good time. They shared a lot of the same dreams and had hoped to become successful in life.
The Band’s Visit
ReplyDeleteMovie: Bikur Ha-Tizmoret
Director: Eran Kolirin
Starring: Sasson Gabai, Ronit Elkabetz, Saleh Bakri
Year: 2007
The Band’s Visit is a minimalistic portrayal of the human emotion but still manages to paint a colorful portrait of the commoner’s sensibility. There is a humor that presents a comical situation to the viewer and compels him to be amused by it based on his social experiences and norms, then there is another that presents a completely logical picture, but the way it is presented is nothing short of hilarious. The Band’s Visit is a perfect example of this approach of subtle passive humor. The Israeli-Arab conflict is an issue of great significance to the region. And any media produced by either side, is a form of political message highly suitable to public scrutiny. The most impressive feature of the film is that it portrays the cultural conflict all the while avoiding any political undertones. As a matter of fact, it fosters a feeling of tolerance and acceptance towards the differences between cultures.
The story follows the Alexandria Police Orchestra that arrives in Israel from Egypt with the objective of performing at a cultural center. But due to a miscommunication, they end up in the isolated town of Bet Hatikva in the middle of a desert. With no transportation or means for getting to their intended destination, they are offered a place to stay by a local restaurant owner named Dina for the night. What follows is a comical journey of how each member spends the night.
The film utilizes very little dialogue with most of it being in English. The music score presents soft Arabic lyrics that gel well with the setting and nature of the story. Overall the film is cast really well and is generally well acted and sincere. A lot of the dialogue delivered is by Sasson Gabai, who portrays the character of the hapless orchestra group leader Tawfiq Zacharya. He is quite exceptional with the way he brings in an air of colonial Egyptian values and charm and holds the rest of the plot together by providing the actual substance to drive the story. The only negative is that the film depicts Israel as a tourist destination for all the wrong reasons.
I could best compare the passive humor of the film with Art School confidential. The film is not a laugh riot but more of a feel good film that leaves you a little relaxed and at peace with yourself. The Band’s Visit is funny yet the lovable characters can easily make you cry. It is a strong recommendation for anyone into the regional politics and culture simply because it is too unique and rare to be missed.