Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Comments on The Class (France, 2008)

Please post your comments on The Class (Entre les Murs) below . . .

12 comments:

  1. Knowing that this movie was in the education genre sparked my interest from the beginning and I have to say it held my interest all the way through. I was surprised to find that the school in this movie was an exact replica of my high school back home. The students have no respect for the teacher or at least don’t show it. The teacher either throws the troublemakers out of class just so he or she doesn’t have to deal with them or the teacher feeds into the students’ disruption, which simply causes more problems. Then the administration doesn’t know what to do to punish the students. Expulsion doesn’t work because it only gives the troublemakers what they want-a get out of jail free card so to speak. It was nice to see that schools in other countries have the same problems as schools in America. Maybe other countries shouldn’t insult America so much when they should be looking in the mirror.
    But that’s just the surface of the movie. There are underlying messages, I feel, being displayed. First of all, the school can only do so much to help the students lead a good life. After a point, the parent needs to step in and raise his or her child properly. If the home life is not good, then the teachers and administrators cannot expect the student to perform well. Secondly, the last scene is probably the most important. Teachers and students are getting along, having a great time playing soccer, but then we see an empty classroom with desk chairs all in disarray. This shows that in a classroom setting students might feel pressured by their teacher which is why they respond the way they do. Also, the teacher may come off as being better than the students because he or she is in control and tells the students what to do. Lastly, this film shows the age at which teenagers are their most expressive and must be dealt with carefully because they feel that all adults are against them. So to keep them from getting defensive and violent, teachers must speak to them a certain way to avoid bad situations.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Its hard to sit and watch this chaos happen. The Class makes you want to reach out and speak and touch these children. Don’t they see they are only hurting themselves? This story is a story that many people have heard about but not actually seen. We here of the chaos and unruliness in classrooms in America all the time, is this the only place that this happens. What I took from this movie is that Europeans and American children are very similar. I never really tried especially hard in school and at times I might have been as disrespectful as the students. I didn’t think that that type of behavior was going on in France or in any other culture. Americans are stamped with the idea that we are fat, lazy and stupid by the European world. I took a couple things from this movie but the main thing is that children don’t want to learn they want to live, but they must be made to learn.
    The teacher in this film was a little to vocal for me. If I would have had a teacher that would make me explain my illogical comments and insults it would have ruined the class. Meaning I would have continuous ridiculed and belittled him. I can’t believe he did nothing while the African American child said that he thought that he was gay. The teacher was playing right into their hands. I know he didn’t want to be like the other teachers who constantly where throwing their children out but you have to in a situation like that. The children aren’t there on their own accord; it’s the law that they have come to school. You can’t be someone’s best friend like the teacher was trying to do and instruct them at the same time it doesn’t work.
    Another view I got into teaching was the fact that you cant help everyone. You cant help the child that is quiet and isn’t learning anything, just like you cant help the child that will be sent back to his village if he is expelled. There are sad stories within every school and we just got an inside look into one.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Entre les Murs. Between the walls of the school, there are frustrated teachers, frustrated students, and distraught parents. There is an urgency and a laxity, glimmers of interest and a boatload of apathy. The same feelings are present in the audience watching The Class. The French title really is more apt to describe the film, the claustrophobia that comes with only being allowed within the walls of the school. I felt myself experiencing some of the same emotions I felt back in high school and middle school, those of apathy and a general lack of interest and frustration. In this way, the film was successful. We are meant to feel an emotional response to film. In this case, I could feel the frustration of François and the desire to help. I could feel the sting of the insults the students felt as well as their occasional curiosity.
    I was intrigued by the cultural differences shown by the film. I have learned of the racial and ethnic tensions and of the difficulties with immigration, but it was different to watch it play out. The students are engrained with a different set of ideals, yet the classroom was similar to some in this country and in others. Education is an imperfect system everywhere. The teachers and students must learn from each other and do what they can to educate each other. That relies on a lot of things. It relies on interest and information and cooperation and respect. That is a lot to anticipate coming together every day. I was not surprised when the one teacher lost his cool in the teacher’s lounge and expressed his frustrations with his students. I’m surprised it did not happen more often. After a while watching the film, I wanted to do the same. I was frustrated and annoyed both on behalf of the students and of the teachers. I found immense relief when the school bells finally rang and it was time for class to end. Though I’m glad I have seen this film and I think it has a lot of important things to say, it is not one that I would volunteer to watch again.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Directed by Laurent Cantet, The Class, is a dramatic film that shows inside the walls of a French public school. The protagonist of the film is Francois and he does not play the normal hero like many school films of this genre. Most films in the same genre as The Class such as Freedom Writers, show the roughness of public schools and will always have the teacher “save the day“ in the end. This film is an exception because the teacher is caught in a difficult situation that would and could actually happen in real life. This is why the film was so entertaining to me because I did not know what to expect in the end. I didn’t know what the teacher should do because it was a lose-lose situation for him. I could not predict the end. Cantet leaves many things ambiguous in the end including what happens to Wie and what happens to Souleymayne.
    The entire time throughout the film, I struggled to recognize Francois character. It only shows him in the classroom setting so I could not full understand his personality. He handled the classroom differently than I would have expected an experience teacher to handle it. When students would ask him off topic questions he would answer with other off topic questions instead of returning to the subject matter being taught.
    The film was shot as a documentary as a “fly on the wall” scenario. I think this was great because if gave the audience the sense that they were actually in the class. I felt like I was one of the students going through the struggles of everyday classroom activities. The French Education system differs a lot from the American Education system such as how the class reps would get to hear their fellow classmates’ grades. I am in the secondary education program at Hanover and I really enjoyed this movie because I gave me a look at how some schools really are. It did not just have a happy ending, but a real life ending that could actually happen. As a future teacher, I still cannot find a solution to what I would do if I were in Francois situation.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This education film may feel like watching a documentary rather than a full length motion picture film, but the thoughts underlying this film what makes the film successful. This film puts though first, then its characters second, and it places the importance of the plot last. This film does have a plot, but it is not a concrete plot that keeps you on edge with unexpected twists and reversals like most movies produced in Hollywood. In the film, one of the students acts out in class and gets himself expelled from school. If this were a Hollywood movie, it is likely that the boy would have came back to school with a gun or threatened the teacher and/or students in some way until the teacher could bring the boy to a sort of agreement. Instead of creating suspense by threatening the lives of the students, it keeps all of the situations to a more realistic level (keeping it on more of a day to day basis with nothing too out of the ordinary). It does not contain that Hollywood suspense, but it does build up gradual tension throughout the movie through arguments and other conflicts created between the students and the teacher. The director, Laurent Cantet, decided to create this movie in a way that depicts students and teachers within a classroom in what seems to be real circumstances. It is very realistic. The film seems very realistic because the students that are acting in it appear average. They are not selected superstar actors, but they are real students who say things that students would actually say in that given circumstance rather than having an older person writing down their lines for them to react. “The Class” contains events are brought up and are never taken anywhere and even leaves some unanswered for you to question yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The Class is an interesting film. I haven’t seen a movie with that kind of structure before and I’m not sure if I liked it or not. But the film was not boring by any means, I never once found myself wanting it to be over because it was too dull. I think that it is a great insight into how the classroom operates and a good way to show what inner city children’s lives are like as well as how teachers deal with the problems. I found myself frustrated with the students several times throughout the movie, I have never found myself in a classroom in which the students behaved so poorly but after awhile it seemed to me that the teacher wasn’t handling some of the situations in an effective enough way to maintain order. There were also a couple of scenes that brought about a feeling of concern for some of the students like Wei’s mother being deported and the kid getting expelled for disrupting the class because he might have to go back to his family in Mali.
    I really liked what the movie had to say about inner city schools, that many of the students have problems at home and the teachers can’t really do a lot about it, and it was interesting to see how the French school system works, the classes are not split by age only, it’s a mixture of age and skill level. What I didn’t like about the movie was that it seemed to lack a plot, I know that it had several small unfinished plots but what I didn’t like was that none questions about the students lives were answered.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The Class

    Movie: Entre les murs
    Director: Laurent Cantet
    Starring: Fracois Begaudeau
    Year: 2008

    If it is believed that truth is stranger than fiction, then Laurent Cantet’s The Class may very well be the center piece of the educational drama genre. The setting is fairly elementary. A motivated teacher decides to take up the role of redeeming and inspiring a class of delinquents towards self emancipation that the educational system has failed to provide. But unlike films such as Freedom Writers and Dangerous Minds, The Class escapes the mould of being overtly melodramatic and instead emphasizes on a more realistic approach. The whole movie is shot in what appears to be a documentary format with minimalistic direction or script. Francois Begaudeau, the writer of the story portrays himself in the lead role of Francois, while the actual students portray the students in class. This gives a great sense of authenticity to the story and the characters.

    As the film progresses, the characters and their problems are revealed and sub plots begin to emerge. The focus is on the story instead of the characters and that is why we rarely leave the school. Francois is not depicted as a perfect teacher either, and is susceptible to human tendencies. While this helps the story develop, the real strength of the story is in its contextual idea of forcing the viewer to raise questions and not provide them with the answers. Cantet ingeniously riddles the movie with a magnitude of social dilemmas that the French society faces today and disguises it in debates about football. One of the best scenes in the film shows how Carl, a French boy of Caribbean descent says how he supports the French football team even though he maintains a distinct Caribbean identity for himself. He gives the examples of Diarra and Henry, who play for the French team while being of foreign heritage and also dislikes Materazzi who had fouled Zidane a french player of Algerian Arab descent in an important game. While on another occasion there is a debate on how the black Frenchmen of Arabic descent supports other black nations over Arab ones in the African nation’s cup. On another occasion the cultural difference between the interpretations of shame is depicted. While some of the undertones of the film are obvious, others may remain elusive to the average viewer.

    Cantet manages to keep a global audience entertained by presenting a fairly basic school setting and the problems that minority students face while masterfully presenting some of the social and cultural issues that much of Europe faces today.

    ReplyDelete
  9. How can a movie that has no plot be interesting? That was my question after watching The Class; an interesting French movie that lacks a traditional plot. Instead of an exciting plot, this movie totally relies on its characters to make it interesting, and does a very good job of it. The characters are realistic, as the movie was based on a real story, and there is nothing extraordinary about anybody in the movie. The audience is moved as the teacher, François, tries his best to teach a group of intercity Parisian students around the age of twelve.

    François’s teaching tactics are some of the most attractive aspects of the movie. It is obvious that he cares very much about his students, but the students do not always care for him. He tries his best to better understand them, and alienates some of them in the process. I was a little surprised of François’s conduct of the class. Instead of taking control of the class and teaching them, it seemed he wasted a lot of talking in circles with the students, who wanted the time to be wasted. It could be that François was trying to live up to a national ideal, where the students were equals to the teacher- aspects of Égalité and Fraternité. He treated his pupils as if they were equals, rather than their boss. When he had a disagreement with students, he would directly speak to them, sort of like one would speak to a work associate, rather than a student.

    One reason that it is so easy to criticize François’s teaching is because the movie makes it very easy to imagine oneself in the character’s shoes. While watching The Class, it is easy to imagine oneself as François, but it is also easy to watch him from an outside perspective. His interactions with the students make The Class interesting and fun to watch.

    ReplyDelete
  10. After watching action movies it was good to watch such a simple film. Sometimes simple is the best way to go. The Class showed a classroom from the beginning of school and ended with the last day. It really created an emotional experience. Marin’s class had it all. The adolescents ranged from intelligent, artistic, rude and disturbing. Marin seemed to always compose himself. If he did have tension it was because all of the minor things that happened in the class. One of the film’s best features was it showed the education system from a different prospective. The classes did not meet every day and the class had student representatives that were allowed to overhear meetings. This would never fly in our society. The class was full of mostly annoying students and reminded me of high school. We would have to call in specific student teachers and substitutes to handle our, “bad classes.” One thing the producer did that seemed to be really effective was only focus on the teacher’s professional environment and not show many scenes outside of the classroom. This technique almost forces the audience to stay tuned of what is happening in the classroom. The producer also made the audience put themselves in Marin’s shoes. I pictured myself talking to the class as he was trying to make them become better students. It also fired up our emotions. When the adolescents misbehaved it made us angry and irritated at them. In the previous films we have watched it has been pretty apparent who the protagonist is. I feel like only half of the audience might say Mr. Marin is the hero. He did have to put up with a lot during the school year, but at the same time he did some things that could have gotten him fired. He called the two girls sluts near the end of the film which could have changed the way the audience viewed him and also initially lose sympathy for him. Personally, I feel like Marin did a good job. He might of let a few comments slip but he realized how important is was to keep Souleymane in school. He had good intentions and tried to convince the other teachers to vote him to stay. I would change just one thing about this film. It was good that it focused only in school because it helped the audience stay focused. The last half of the movie kind of revolved around Souleymane’s hearing. It would have been nice to maybe show how Souleymane was doing in other classes. Not only him, but it would have been a good addition to the film to see how the kids were doing in other classes. It might have spiced up the film if Laurent showed scenes from another class. The audience should have sympathy for all the teachers there, because they each had to put up with the students during the year. Since the audience only viewed one class, it limited them to who they can feel sorry for.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The Class, or Between the Walls, was one of those films that by the end the audience is intrigued and left asking multiple questions. However, it accomplished this in a different way than most films. There is no grand plot based on fictional events with multiple twists and turns. It is simply real people dealing with real problems and situations; and that itself is the intrigue. Yes it is nice to drift off into a fictional world every once in awhile but it is also equally as nice to be grounded in reality at times and Laurent Cantet did an excellent job at giving the audience this experience.

    One aspect that really plays apart in the ability for the audience to grasp the film fully is that it is very focused. Every scene, every problem, every moment is dealt with at the school, between the walls. This allows the audience to be very much captivated with the events that take place and connect with characters in one way or another. And yet, this focus can also leave a lot of questions unanswered. For example does Souleymane get sent to Mali, what happens with Wei’s family, what was the fight between Khoumba and Esmeralda about, and why did Carl transfer to this new school? Some may see unanswered questions as a fault but the fact is that Cantet got the audience to wonder and to think outside the walls of the school.

    Though the audience is able to think outside the walls, the film is in a way contained in those walls which makes it rather difficult at times to fully understand the characters personality. The teacher François, for instance, is particularly hard to read. At times one may find themselves understanding his approach to teaching but other times it is hard to keep from wondering why he is baiting the students on.

    The great thing about this film is that it is just one moment in reality, one glimpse of how their lives are like. And for that moment the audience can experience the lives, the reality, of the characters.

    ReplyDelete