Friday, May 21, 2010
4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days by Audrey Hanner
Gabita made mistakes and now wants to erase them, but it is illegal. Gabita has lost the freedom to alter her body. Watching how Gabita goes about to lose her child is very realistic and unpleasant. The director puts the audience in a real life situation, which was not a pleasant situation. The director did not choose a movie of love and happiness, but of realism. Being put into this horrid situation makes the audience think deeper.
The director, Christian Mungiu, decided to use no background music in this film. This is a risky move, since almost every Hollywood film emphasizes the use of background music. Many of us are extremely used to having many known bands play for movies and buying the soundtracks, but not this movie. Not using music fit in with the movie and was a good choice. There was a time when Otilia was walking in the dark to get rid of the fetus, the audience could hear footsteps and cars, but no creepy, scary music alluring to what will happen next. The silence makes the revolting storyline seem much more meaningful.
The color of the movie was very muted. Everything was dark, no bright colors. The director was setting the scene for a grim story with the subdued colors.
The director did a good job at making the audience uncomfortable, irritated, anxious and frightened. This movie does not hide the emotionally uncomfortable situations that most people do not like shown dead on into their faces. This movie might make one uncomfortable, but all in all it is a good movie and definitely should be seen.
4 Months, 3 Weeks, 2 Days
The film’s setting was dark and gloomy which added to the tension of the film. There was never a part throughout the film where I felt comfortable, meaning I was always suspecting something to go wrong with the abortion. Even at the end of the film, when Gabita is seating at the table looking calm and collected, I still thought something was going to go wrong. That’s what makes this film so special because the audience is not supposed to feel comfortable. Munglu wants the audience to feel like they are in the film, struggling with what is going on. I was hoping that Gabita would rethink what she is doing and actually have the baby, which of course does not happen.
The scene that made me the most uncomfortable was not actually the scene where the probe was being put into Gabita. Yes, the abortion was terrible to watch, but I knew what was going to happen. I was the most uncomfortable when Otilia was at her boyfriend’s parents’ house eating dinner. For about 10 minutes (which seemed like an eternity), the camera shot is positioned on Otilia and does not move. The people around Gabita are conversing mindlessly, even calling her family “simple,” while she desperately wants to get back to see Gabita. I just wanted to yell at the screen for Otilia to go back to Gabita because she could be dead (at least that’s what I thought was happening). This kind of shows the beauty of Munglu. He takes a scene that was supposed to be happy (girl eating at boyfriend’s parents’ house for a birthday party) and makes it one of the most uncomfortable and memorable parts of the film: true genius.
Mongol by Audrey Hanner
The beautiful, white wolf at first look seemed to symbolize the Mongolian god, Tengri. When the enemies make the wolf reference of “it doesn’t matter how far a wolf runs, he always comes back to home” they are talking about Temudgin. It is then that the audience can see that wolf represents the god, but also Temudgin. Temudgin is like a god to the Mongolian people because he united them all and brought a sense of peace. The enemies refer to Temudgin more as coming back to their house. Though Temudgin always returns home, not an actual building he calls his house, but his wife. Temudgin always returns to Borte, whether it has been a year or ten.
Temudgin seemed to completely forget about Targuati. Temudgin’s mother told Targuati that he would avenge his father’s death, though he never did. It was because of Targuati that he had some many problems in his life; though if Temudgin did not have that hard life, he never would have become the “Great Khan.” In the beginning the audience is made to believe that Temudgin was going to avenge his father’s death and save his clan, but he only cared to save his wife and children, and the Mongolian culture.
"The Band's Visit" - Dylan Brenner
“The Band’s Visit” is a quiet movie, if nothing else. The characters communicate and interact with little dialogue, but body language and the sense of uncomfortable racial tensions create as full of a conversation as a verbal one. The dialogue is so scarce for most of the film, that the few scenes with long conversations, the scene with Dina and Tawfiq in the park for example, seem too wordy. This verbal scarcity is a mechanic of a film I have never really encountered before but due to that fact, was even more effective.
Even with verbal scarcity, “The Band’s Visit” is a comedic film. Yet instead of wisecracks and verbal sparring that many of us are accustomed to seeing in comedies, Kolirin frames most of his humor in simple, elegant images. The best example of this is the roller disco scene, most of which is funny. The culmination of this humor is in the coaching scene where Haled is helping Papi win over his date. The shot is basically devoid of dialogue but still left me in stitches. Those type of scenes showcase Kolirin’s gifted eye for memorable shots and his sense of visual humor.
“The Band’s Visit” was a funny film that managed to not feel frivolous or sentimental. The film was expertly crafted with dialogue, visuals, and soundtrack but the true genius of the filmmaker was showcased in his cinematography. The film leaves a positively beautiful impression and is likely a story I would be excited to revisit.
4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days was an interesting depiction of how a communist state operates and having seen it, I have learned things about the lifestyle that some of the communist countries hade during the cold war era. It was interesting to see what lengths people had to go through to get things done, and I didn’t know that cigarettes were so valuable to that type of society. Having said that, as informative, and well made as the movie was, I didn’t like it. Even though the 4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days was exceedingly depressing, which is why I didn’t like the movie, doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s a bad one, I just don’t like depressing movies that don’t have an ending to the story. The story line was not very eventful up to a certain point and up to the part when one of the main character’s lives is in danger due to an illegal abortion, I didn’t find it very suspenseful. However, after the abortion, the suspense doesn’t go away and we are left worrying about her health for almost half the movie and we never really find out how she is doing as the credits abruptly start rolling while the two main characters are sitting at a table in the hotel restaurant. There were also a couple of scenes that I thought dragged on, one of them being the scene that the main character is looking for a place to throw away the fetus and it looks like she is being followed another one would be the scene in the hotel room were the “doctor” is to explaining everything to the two women. Overall I left the movie feeling a lot more depressed than I did when I was before the movie started, but then again if that’s what the movie was going for then it did its job well.
4 months, 3 weeks, and 2 days-Sara Ferriell
The film did not give us warm and fuzzies. I didn't want to get happy feelings. I wanted to feel the rawness. The fear. The uncomfortableness. These emotions are largely due to the filming style. The long takes don't let let you look away when things get uncomfortable. Whew. And things got uncomfortable. We watch Gabita get an abortion in a dirty hotel room from a sleazebag pig of a man. I wanted to look away, but couldn't. Not even when you see a shot of the fetus, in a bath towel. The stress is included when we follow Otilia in her search for somewhere to deposit the fetus in a shot where the camera itself is ran with, jostling the image and heightening the experience of the audience. It's not steady and smooth. It's rough and it's nerve wracking. And terribly effective.
The Band's Visit-Sara Ferriell
Much like other little honest films, the budget was not extravagant and the film is not self indulgent. It's refreshingly honest. It takes a subject that could become trivial and makes it sweet and introverted. We have all felt what those characters feel. We have been lost and had to rely on others. We've had to sit in uncomfortable silences, unsure of what to do next. The film shows that even those from different cultures entirely can share experiences and both benefit from them. Yes. Let's teach the world to sing, in perfect harmony. The film does not feel cliche, as it easily could have. The performances are not forced or overwrought. The story is not forced through dialogue and includes a subtlety and many American films lack entirely. The film is sweet, but not trivial. It is touching and heartwarming, yet not obnoxious. I found myself moved and grinning when the film wrapped up. The laughs were honest and not contrived and the overall experience of the film is something largely missing from cinema. I know I'll keep an eye out for a stranded Egyptian police band in the future. Perhaps they are in need of some kindness.