Friday, May 21, 2010
4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days - Andi Chipman
The subject of abortion is not something that most people want to discuss or think about let alone watch in a movie, especially in that particular time period. It is a very sore and sticky subject and Mungui does not hide anything. He shows nearly every detail about Gabita’s abortion and what Otilia and she had to go through in order to get it done. It is awful to think that something like that could and may have actually happened.
Part of what made this movie real is the actors. They looked like real people and not fake like most of the A-list actors that we tend to see on tv. Anamaria Marinca did a wonderful job at playing her character Otilia. The role must have a been a bit difficult for her to do since she was just a child during the reign of Nicolae Ceausesou and that is a situation that she is probably not familiar with. However, I think that she did a wonderful job at playing the brave roommate that has to take care of her roommate. Laura Vasiliu also did an outstanding job at playing Gabita, the needy roommate that is afraid to do anything on her own.
4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days is the type of movie that I would only watch once. In my opinion it is neither good nor bad. It just is. It does it’s job of informing the audience about what a woman would have to go through in order to get an abortion during a time when communism was everywhere and abortion was illegal. It would have been a terrible time and place to live it and this would be case where ignorance is bliss.
Delhi-6
The plot of this film was very complex so some of the smaller parts of it were lost completely. The screenplay seemed to be well crafted but it seemed as if the screenwriter had too many ideas and not enough space to put them all in. The movie was full of metaphors and symbols and tried to address the religious issues apparent in Delhi as well as some of its crime issues. Overall it seemed there was too much going on with the plot, but luckily the film has so many other aspects to it that it is still exceptionally entertaining.
In the end the film seems to rely mostly on its score and scenery to impress and entertain the viewer. The complex plot is definitely present but is overshadowed by the amazing live theater visuals and the sudden music interludes. The film has a few cliché metaphors and the take home message is just that Muslims and Hindus are the same. The movie is purely for entertainment purposes because the moral of the story is one that a regular movie watcher has heard time and time again and offers nothing new to think about.
Mongol
Mongol brings excitement and untold (probably fictitious) stories about Genghis Khan to life. Known in the movie as Temudjin in the movie, Genghis Khan was a boy who would suffer much pain in his early years. In the beginning of the film, Temudjin picks his bride, Borte, and shows great determination and loyalty to her throughout the movie, just as she does for him. Because Temudjin is the son of an assassinated Khan, he is constantly running away from his enemies. While the theme of love exist in the movie, it is relatively irrelevant. I thought their love seemed pretty unrealistic. Temudjin continues to return to his wife throughout the movie, but it seems that he only spends about a week at a time with her; it seems likely that Temudjin’s family’s role in the film were not necessary in a film that was full of so much action. The real focus of the film is on Temudjin’s struggle to defeat his enemies. He is obviously a very determined man; at one point he is caged like an animal, but continues to fight his enemies until he brings law and order to the Mongols.
I was surprised about the amount of time the movie spent on Temudjin’s early days, when he was running away. Personally, I thought it got a little old watching him promising to avenge his enemies. I expected to see more of Genghis Khan’s rise, and the movie skipped that part entirely. It went from having Temudjin being a slave to him being a powerful warlord in minutes. I would have rather seen a story about his rise to power than his made up family. I guess I just thought that would be more fitting.
The Band's Visit
Most of the humor throughout the film does not come from the dialogue because there is not a lot of dialogue going on. The body language of the characters and the camera shots Kolirin uses provide the humor of the film. The scene at the roller-skating rink proved to be my favorite scene of the entire film. It was a classic situation of the “ladies man” trying to show the “shy” guy different tactics to get the girl. Although there is very little dialogue on the bench that all three were sitting at, I was laughing out loud through the whole thing. It was something so simple as trying to get a girl but it becomes so comical.
I really enjoyed the ending of the movie. All the subplots come together as everyone falls asleep and wakes up in the morning. Then the next scene shows the band playing at their show and skipping how they actually got to the location. I felt like this was a great way to end it because it shows Tawfiq in his highest element of happiness conducting the orchestra.
4 Months, 3 Weeks, and 2 Days
One of the most interesting things about this film is the way it is shot, with numerous long shots and not much editing. These long takes submerse you in the film; you can truly believe you are sitting at the hectic dinner table with Otilia hearing the unanswered phone constantly ring. It’s amazing how engrossed you can become in the film. For example when Otilia is finally trying to get rid of the fetus and is running around in the dark alleys. The shot is a long one that seems to have no cuts, you just follow Otilia around in the almost pitch darkness. The camera at this point is a little jittery and the diegetic sounds of Otilia walking, dogs barking, and people yelling is completely unnerving to the viewer.
This film does an amazing job of documenting life in 20th century communist Romania. The director throws you directly into the lives of people in 1987 and it is incredibly shocking. The purpose is to make sure we don’t forget what those times were like, and it is impossible to ever forget this film. It takes you on an emotional and stressful 113 minute ride and leaves you stunned and astounded at the end.
Delhi 6 - Dylan Brenner
“Delhi 6” is unique in the fact that the music backing the story is not simply dramatic but relative to the current plotline being explored. The music stands alone as a pleasant experience, especially for western audiences who rarely get exposed to the exotic sounds of eastern musicians. The music interludes drive the plot forward and aid in characterization and although they seem a little cheesy, without them the film would just seem bland.
The film is exceptional indeed, but it is not without its flaws. The dialogue was often obvious and there are several instances where metaphors are used which could be called thinly-veiled at best. This issue is not a true flaw, as the language barrier does make translating metaphor a challenge. Only so much emotional depth can be carried in subtitles. Another flaw in the overall film is the standard plot and message that ultimately drove the film. It was a cultural roots story, which dissolved into a realm of religious debate before resolving with a message of equality. The plot was well crafted but there are only so many ways to dress up a tired idea.
“Delhi 6” is a great film with an amazing soundtrack and I for one would like to explore more of Mehran’s work. He is indeed a gifted filmmaker and with his talent could craft perfect movies if he finds some fresh source material to work from.
Mongol: The rise of Genghis Khan
Mongol: The rise of Genghis Khan was a surprisingly very well made movie. I say that it is surprisingly very well made because it came out of Kazakhstan, a country that I never would have thought would have a very strong movie industry, if any. This was a very exciting and action packed film even though a lot of the fight scenes were implied, especially when he got back from the city and started forming his clan all over again to the point that he was battling his deceased fathers clan and his blood brother’s clan, and there wasn’t a single spot in the movie that I found myself thinking that it was dragging on and that I just wanted it to be over, but at the end of the movie I found myself wishing that it would go on and share more of the story, but I was ok with the story being cut short when I found out that it was the first of three movies. I found the movie very informative about the difficulties that the Mongols had to deal with in everyday life and I also learned about what the culture was like as well. I’m not sure how much of the story is true, but I found it interesting that the little boy that became Genghis Khan escaped death at least twice and then became the leader of his own clan only to be captured and sold as a slave, and then come back to become the Khan of all of Mongol. Not to quote what was said in lecture about this movie, but I do agree that this movie does have a brave heart feeling to it a little boy loses his parents has to grow up with someone else, comes back an adult, an event happens causing to protagonist to seek revenge, and the protagonist successfully gets his revenge