With an acclaimed auteur like Pedro Almodovar, sometimes it is hard for me to separate the artist from the work. Sometimes, this can result in a positive experience, gaining insight into the mind of a gifted, inspirational filmmaker, and sometimes, it’s simply masturbatory. For me, Almodovar’s “Broken Embraces” falls somewhere in between. Almodovar is, concededly, a very gifted filmmaker with an eye for striking images and suspenseful plot. However, it seems he fell somewhere off the mark here. In this twisted, multi-layered story of betrayal and revenge in the Spanish film industry, we’re offered stellar performances by Lluis Homar and crossover star Penelope Cruz, a staple of Almodovar’s work. The former portrays what seems to be the stand-in for Almodovar himself; the gifted filmmaker who, many years ago, made a film with the same script as Almodovar’s Oscar-nominated “Women On the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown”. In this film, the title is changed to “Women and Suitcases”, with Penelope Cruz as the actress who catches the heart of the filmmaker himself. Forgive me if I sound vulgar, but this film came off to me as a Pedro Almodovar wet-dream, involving him and Penelope Cruz banging behind-the-scenes and running away together. Even in his old age and disabled state, the lead character played Homar, Harry Caine, seems to be able to just pick up young, attractive women off the street and seduce them practically effortlessly. All I could think about as the credits rolled was how badly Almodovar must wish he were Harry Caine. The young, renegade filmmaker whose genius work, loved by all, was mercilessly stolen and butchered by the evil production company, and all the while he’s bedding every young starlet who crosses his path. If there were a James Bond of the motion picture industry, Harry Caine is pretty close. Pedro, next time, leave the daydreams in your journal. You’re better than that. -Jon Becraft
Broken Embraces is a beautiful romantic tragedy directed by Pedro Almodóvar that illustrates a critical part of a writer’s life. This film leaves many things purposely unanswered, but that only serves to create a desire in the viewer to watch the movie again. The film uses numerous flashbacks to present Mateo Blanco’s life and explain why he is now known as Harry Caine. The film also uses numerous shot techniques, so not only is the story beautiful to hear, it is also beautiful to watch. One major question the film leaves open is if Mateo is truly blind or not.
I think this topic is one that is truly at the center of the meaning of the film. After Mateo Blanco is in the car accident he is sent to the hospital where the doctor explains he has “cortical blindness.” This type of blindness is caused not by damage from the eyes, but damage to the visual area in the brain’s occipital lobe. This damage would be hard to detect and very easy to fake. Some people who have cortical blindness express hallucinations, as well as denial of visual-loss, and even the Riddoch phenomenon. The Riddoch phenomenon is one in which people can perceive motion but not actual static objects. It is my opinion that Mateo Blanco is actually able to see and that he has merely given up sight when he is forced to give up Lena. Films and visuals are Mateo’s life, and after he meets Lena, she becomes his life. Therefore it seems reasonable to believe that when Mateo loses Lena, he understands that he needs to lose his vision and old persona and fully become Harry Caine. Yet once Mateo becomes Harry and stops using his sight, it seems possible that his sight is truly lost, which is why at the end of the film once he becomes Mateo once more, he still cannot see, just as he can truly never forget Lena.
Bueno. Magnífico. Súper. These are all words to describe Pedro Almodovar’s film Broken Embraces. It has tragedy and romance, which are two of my favorite genres. The plot is wonderful and full of surprises and the actors are great too. Penélope Cruz was amazing as well as Lluís Homar. Penélope Cruz does a wonderful job with her character of Lena. It is a shame that she ended up dying. That was one part of the film that was predictable. The only thing that surprised me was how late it was and that it potentially was an accident. That part was a bit off for me. Harry accuses Ernesto Jr. of killing Lena but that was proven wrong. However, he never looks into Ernesto Sr. as being the one in the driver seat of the car. If you think about it then it very well could be possible, but as an audience we’ll never know. Lluís Homar did a good job at playing Harry the blind writer and Mateo the film director. The two were very different yet very much the same. It was nice to see Homar’s character come full circle in confronting the past and finally coming to terms with it. It is hard to believe that it took him fourteen years to do it, but if it was not for Ernesto Jr. then he probably never would have done or just waited longer. I love the story within the story. Hearing what happened to Mateo fourteen years ago through the eyes of his personality afterwards, Harry, was amazing. It was completely unexpected from the way that the film began, you never would have thought of it. Having a plotline where one character becomes his pseudonym after a horrific car accident is not something that you see everyday. Pedro Almodovar did a wonderful job. Kudos to Pedro Almodovar for making a wonderful film and incorporating so many things that I love about movies. I look forward to seeing is other movies.
O the Drama! Broken Embraces is full of drama and romance, but humor can also be found throughout the movie in clever little spots. The movie is so melodramatic, it becomes ridiculous, and many parts of the movie are laughable. Because of my little knowledge of Spanish Cinema, I am positive that I missed many humorous moments in the movie, particularly in the first half. Towards the second half of the movie, as the plot began to come together and become more absurd, I began to find the movie knock-out funny.
To me, the first half of the movie required a bit of patience. The plot and characters are very complicated, and are easy to confuse. I did not understand the relevance of many scenes in the beginning of the movie; by the time the scenes were explained, I had forgotten the details of what had happened earlier. It was hard to follow at times, but I think watching the movie a second time would make it more enjoyable. The movie had funny moments, but parts seemed to drag on, probably because I had didn’t understand some of the references the movie made. For instance, I found the scenes where they were recording the movie with Lena very boring. As the movie went on, and the plot came together, began to find the movie funny. Confessions and guilt from Mateo and Judit’s past mistakes became eminent towards the end of the film, and it became much more enjoyable, and very funny. I would like to watch some of the director’s other films, and re-watch Broken Embraces; I think it the knowledge of some of the director’s earlier films would make Broken Embraces funnier and more entertaining.
Broken Embraces is an interesting movie full of drama and humor. The complicated plot and characters are not particularly exciting, but are still enjoyable. I think a second viewing of the movie would make the movie funnier, as it might be easier to understand some of the humor found in this very melodramatic movie.
With an acclaimed auteur like Pedro Almodovar, sometimes it is hard for me to separate the artist from the work. Sometimes, this can result in a positive experience, gaining insight into the mind of a gifted, inspirational filmmaker, and sometimes, it’s simply masturbatory. For me, Almodovar’s “Broken Embraces” falls somewhere in between.
ReplyDeleteAlmodovar is, concededly, a very gifted filmmaker with an eye for striking images and suspenseful plot. However, it seems he fell somewhere off the mark here. In this twisted, multi-layered story of betrayal and revenge in the Spanish film industry, we’re offered stellar performances by Lluis Homar and crossover star Penelope Cruz, a staple of Almodovar’s work. The former portrays what seems to be the stand-in for Almodovar himself; the gifted filmmaker who, many years ago, made a film with the same script as Almodovar’s Oscar-nominated “Women On the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown”. In this film, the title is changed to “Women and Suitcases”, with Penelope Cruz as the actress who catches the heart of the filmmaker himself.
Forgive me if I sound vulgar, but this film came off to me as a Pedro Almodovar wet-dream, involving him and Penelope Cruz banging behind-the-scenes and running away together. Even in his old age and disabled state, the lead character played Homar, Harry Caine, seems to be able to just pick up young, attractive women off the street and seduce them practically effortlessly. All I could think about as the credits rolled was how badly Almodovar must wish he were Harry Caine. The young, renegade filmmaker whose genius work, loved by all, was mercilessly stolen and butchered by the evil production company, and all the while he’s bedding every young starlet who crosses his path. If there were a James Bond of the motion picture industry, Harry Caine is pretty close. Pedro, next time, leave the daydreams in your journal. You’re better than that.
-Jon Becraft
Broken Embraces is a beautiful romantic tragedy directed by Pedro Almodóvar that illustrates a critical part of a writer’s life. This film leaves many things purposely unanswered, but that only serves to create a desire in the viewer to watch the movie again. The film uses numerous flashbacks to present Mateo Blanco’s life and explain why he is now known as Harry Caine. The film also uses numerous shot techniques, so not only is the story beautiful to hear, it is also beautiful to watch. One major question the film leaves open is if Mateo is truly blind or not.
ReplyDeleteI think this topic is one that is truly at the center of the meaning of the film. After Mateo Blanco is in the car accident he is sent to the hospital where the doctor explains he has “cortical blindness.” This type of blindness is caused not by damage from the eyes, but damage to the visual area in the brain’s occipital lobe. This damage would be hard to detect and very easy to fake. Some people who have cortical blindness express hallucinations, as well as denial of visual-loss, and even the Riddoch phenomenon. The Riddoch phenomenon is one in which people can perceive motion but not actual static objects. It is my opinion that Mateo Blanco is actually able to see and that he has merely given up sight when he is forced to give up Lena. Films and visuals are Mateo’s life, and after he meets Lena, she becomes his life. Therefore it seems reasonable to believe that when Mateo loses Lena, he understands that he needs to lose his vision and old persona and fully become Harry Caine. Yet once Mateo becomes Harry and stops using his sight, it seems possible that his sight is truly lost, which is why at the end of the film once he becomes Mateo once more, he still cannot see, just as he can truly never forget Lena.
-Tori Hopkins
Bueno. Magnífico. Súper. These are all words to describe Pedro Almodovar’s film Broken Embraces. It has tragedy and romance, which are two of my favorite genres. The plot is wonderful and full of surprises and the actors are great too. Penélope Cruz was amazing as well as Lluís Homar.
ReplyDeletePenélope Cruz does a wonderful job with her character of Lena. It is a shame that she ended up dying. That was one part of the film that was predictable. The only thing that surprised me was how late it was and that it potentially was an accident. That part was a bit off for me. Harry accuses Ernesto Jr. of killing Lena but that was proven wrong. However, he never looks into Ernesto Sr. as being the one in the driver seat of the car. If you think about it then it very well could be possible, but as an audience we’ll never know.
Lluís Homar did a good job at playing Harry the blind writer and Mateo the film director. The two were very different yet very much the same. It was nice to see Homar’s character come full circle in confronting the past and finally coming to terms with it. It is hard to believe that it took him fourteen years to do it, but if it was not for Ernesto Jr. then he probably never would have done or just waited longer.
I love the story within the story. Hearing what happened to Mateo fourteen years ago through the eyes of his personality afterwards, Harry, was amazing. It was completely unexpected from the way that the film began, you never would have thought of it. Having a plotline where one character becomes his pseudonym after a horrific car accident is not something that you see everyday. Pedro Almodovar did a wonderful job.
Kudos to Pedro Almodovar for making a wonderful film and incorporating so many things that I love about movies. I look forward to seeing is other movies.
O the Drama! Broken Embraces is full of drama and romance, but humor can also be found throughout the movie in clever little spots. The movie is so melodramatic, it becomes ridiculous, and many parts of the movie are laughable. Because of my little knowledge of Spanish Cinema, I am positive that I missed many humorous moments in the movie, particularly in the first half. Towards the second half of the movie, as the plot began to come together and become more absurd, I began to find the movie knock-out funny.
ReplyDeleteTo me, the first half of the movie required a bit of patience. The plot and characters are very complicated, and are easy to confuse. I did not understand the relevance of many scenes in the beginning of the movie; by the time the scenes were explained, I had forgotten the details of what had happened earlier. It was hard to follow at times, but I think watching the movie a second time would make it more enjoyable. The movie had funny moments, but parts seemed to drag on, probably because I had didn’t understand some of the references the movie made. For instance, I found the scenes where they were recording the movie with Lena very boring. As the movie went on, and the plot came together, began to find the movie funny. Confessions and guilt from Mateo and Judit’s past mistakes became eminent towards the end of the film, and it became much more enjoyable, and very funny. I would like to watch some of the director’s other films, and re-watch Broken Embraces; I think it the knowledge of some of the director’s earlier films would make Broken Embraces funnier and more entertaining.
Broken Embraces is an interesting movie full of drama and humor. The complicated plot and characters are not particularly exciting, but are still enjoyable. I think a second viewing of the movie would make the movie funnier, as it might be easier to understand some of the humor found in this very melodramatic movie.