Out of all of the Holocaust themed movies I have seen, The Counterfeiters is different from them all. This movie shows that there counterfeit money was being made during the Holocaust to save Germany because it was bankrupt. I had no idea that this operation was occurring. This operation led to the discovering of two heroes in this movie-1) Soloman Sorowitsch and 2) Adolf Burger. At first Sally appears to be the hero because when he arrives at Mautchenhausen he saves the operation because he is a professional criminal at counterfeiting. If Sally has an internal conflict with making the counterfeit for the enemy, it is not directly expressed in the movie. However, Burger is the real hero. His decision to not produce counterfeit delayed the production of it, which kept the Nazis from having enough money to take over the British government. One would think that since Burger wrote the book on which the movie is based he would be in the spotlight, but that is not the case. I feel that the depiction of Burger in this form is probably close to him in person. He is one who sticks to his morals and beliefs, even if it means certain death, and does not like being in the spotlight. Another aspect that was different about this movie was that it showed the break-down of the Nazis. In most Holocaust movies, the Nazis are depicted as men who have a one-track mind and only act cruel; they seem to have no feelings. Then all of a sudden they are defeated and gone. However, in The Counterfeiters the Nazis are shown having a desperate side at the end of the war and that they will stoop to anything to stay alive, even asking a criminal to make fake passports so he and his family can escape death for the cruel acts he had committed. Because this movie has such a different take on the Holocaust with very little murder and beating, rather a history lesson that’s entertaining, I feel everyone should see this Oscar-winning film.
When you think of a Holocaust movie, the movie Schlinder’s list comes to mind, along with scenes of death and horror. The Counterfeiters is not like that at all, it does not contain that same amount of suspense that other Holocaust movies do. In the Counterfeiters the audience only saw someone getting shot twice, the friend who got shot in the head and the random man in the shower that did not want to get up. In other Holocaust movies, like Escape from Sobibor, the director shows graphic scenes of Jews being shot and tortured. Without the numerous scenes of someone being shot, the audience does not feel the same amount of despair after the movie. The audience feels more of a sense of hope than of despair.
The Counterfeiters gave the Jews a sense of hope. The Jews that had special talents were treated better than the others, they were given soft beds, weekends off, were beaten very, very rarely, got to shower and were rewarded with a ping pong table. The counterfeiting Jews were given hope and did not have to go searching for it. In most Holocaust movies, like Escape from Sobibor all hope was stripped from the Jews. Jews were not given hope, it was stolen from them. In one scene thirteen Jews had to pick thirteen others to die with them or fifteen would be chosen to die with them by the Nazis. The Jews that were not chosen were told to watch and if they looked away or closed their eyes then they would also die along with the twenty-six already dying. In that movie the Jews had no hope; they had to rely on one another but were forced to kill each other. The Nazi’s gave them no reward or hope, not even false hope. The Jews had to find their own hope and most of them lost it completely. The Counterfeiters were a very special case during that time. The director did a good job at taking most of the suspense out of the movie. The director also did a good job at not creating another blood bath Holocaust movie, but one with hope and different forms of heroes.
This holocaust film is one of a kind. Unlike nearly all of the other films on the holocaust, this one avoids the typical suspense and tension that is created from these terrifying situations. The director, Stefan Ruzowitzky, chose to start the film by revealing its ultimate happy ending. I believe that he chose to start the film in such a way that would relieve the audience from the stress and tension that is built up from the actions leading up to his happy ending. This also serves as an attention getter for the audience because it brings about a sudden interest in how he survived such a horrifying event. This film also depicts the holocaust in an original way. The majority of these types of films depict the pure horror that took place, but “The Counterfeiters” sheds a little bit of light on this grim happening. This film is characterized as a drama because it depicts people under pressure and tension under high stakes in a concentration camp. The jews depicted in this particular concentration camp were living in luxury. They were given soft beds, food, and a weekly shower. A few of those in the concentration camps were happy to have these luxuries, but at the same time they were still dead men. They knew once their work was done that the Nazi’s would kill them. Even the Nazi’s in this film are shown as people just like those in the concentration camps rather than pure evil, unbreakable, and cruel men. They did not want to be there anymore than those being kept as prisoners. This is revealed when one of the Nazi’s makes a deal with the main character, Salomon, to forge him fake passports to get him and his family out of there. This is a great film that allows you to learn from the experience without actually going through it yourself.
Who knew that the Nazi were making Jews counterfeit money for them? They were making them work for them while they killed their friends and families. The Nazi’s sicken me. The most sickening part in the movie to me was when the SS officer allowed Sorowitsch to come to his home. While there the officer paraded him about his house and introduced him to his children. He pretended to be friends with Sorowitsch in front of his family. How can a man raise decent, morale children who has been responsible for the deaths and holocaust of so many people? Another scene that I like was when Burger and Sorowitsch were playing table tennis. Until that moment Sorowitsch had never been public about his morals. Sorowowitsch might have been a criminal but he would have never done the things the Nazi’s did. It’s ironic that Sorowitsch was given a green triangle making his as a criminal. Was he killing thousands of hundreds of people, was he murdering innocent women children and men. Who is the real criminal here? It was funny to see Burger acknowledge the fact that Sorowitsch didn’t want people to see that he has feelings. Even when the boy that Sorowitsch is very close to is murdered we do not see Sorowitsch cry. We hear a deafening sound similar to a grenade exploding right next to our ear, which was a good trick on the part of the director. The whole point of Holocaust films are to make people remember. To never forget the past. The Holocaust happened not at the hands of insane genocidal aliens but by normal men with families. We should never forget these horrible acts so that something like the Holocaust never happens again.
The Counterfeiters is definitely a different view on the holocaust. I am used to movies making a clear distinction between who was good and who was evil, but this movie blurs the lines a bit. Obviously the Nazi’s are bad, but unlike most holocaust movies, some of them are not evil. These men were normal people doing their job, following orders, they had families, and some of them were just trying to survive. It still does not excuse all of the horrible things they did to the Jews. Even though the main character was a criminal, we were still pushing for him to survive, to overcome these horrible things. When the special group of Jew’s was formed to make counterfeit money, they treated them well. The Nazi’s gave the prisoners soft, nice beds they gave them food to keep them healthy, even though just beyond the walls there were other Jews being starved and worked to death. One man had found the passports of his children and therefore believed he had no more reason to live, and the doctor told him he just needed to survive until the war was over. The second the war was over for them the man killed himself, because although he survived, he had no one to survive it for. Burger was the “hero” of the group. He stopped the Nazi’s counterfeit money from being produced. He put everyone’s life on the line every time he would destroy the gelatins, but he knew what the Nazi’s was doing was wrong, so he knew he had a duty to stop it. He did not end up stopping the Nazi’s completely, but he did slow them down greatly. Burger was the character who although he wanted to survive as much as everyone else, he was willing to die for the right thing.
This film is well organized and clever. Making a movie about the holocaust is risky because people in Austria and around the world are still very sensitive. The first scene in the movie is shot at Monte Carlo. The ocean looks refreshing the buildings are classy and the lights are breathtaking. All of these things combined made the opening scene truly exquisite. When Salomon walks into the hotel and opens up the briefcase full of money, it made me think it was going to be a James Bond type of film. Salomon had been living in luxury most of his life and was one of the most famous counterfeiters. After he got arrested the only thing that was keeping him alive was his unique ability to counterfeit. Salomon was put with other Jews that possessed special talents and were treated better. They had some days off and even a hot shower every now and then. What makes this film stand out from is that it does not thrive on being viewed as a thriller. Stefan knew that people in Austria would not want to see a thriller about the Holocaust. One skillfully thing Stefan did was whenever someone got shot, it was very fast. The scene of the person getting shot did not last over 15 seconds and there was not music playing beforehand to build the suspense up. He knew making a film about the Jews and Holocaust would already hit a soft spot in the audience’s hearts; it was good Stefan made the killing scenes as simple as he could. My favorite thing about this film as I watched it was it really forced me to care about what was happening. Throughout this whole movie, Salomon was under pressure. As he was told to do counterfeit in a specific time, I felt my heart racing just as fast as Salomon’s was. The audience began to care about Salomon and wanted to see him survive and make it out of prison. It was good seeing this film because I learned about an experience without actually going through it. It made me realize sometimes we forget how good we have it now. The film not only started with the Mote Carlo scene, but it also ended with it. This was just another clever thing Stefan did. The movie starts off on a positive note and ends on one too. Instead of showing a final fight scene or Salomon in prison, it shows Monte Carlo, which could symbolize happiness.
I have seen my fair share of holocaust films, especially as the subject is fairly common in American cinema. I anticipated that “The Counterfeiters” would be more of the same; gruesome imagery, gray landscapes, and a statement on the cruelty of man. I was surprised to find that all of my expectations of this film were, thankfully, off the mark. “The Counterfeiters” does make a statement on the cruelty of the Holocaust but does so without the gut-wrenching images of depravity that many Hollywood films seem to emphasize. This film presented the Holocaust and the Nazi regime in a way rarely utilized in cinema and thus, created a fresh and dynamic story with common subject matter and leaves you wondering if these characters are as bad as you first believed.
Ruzowitzky shows us the concentration camps from the inside, as his protagonist is arrested and processed into the Nazi prisons. However, instead of leaving the story to run among the squalor and filth of the typical camps, we see the main character Sally taken to live in relative comfort in exchange for supervising the Nazi counterfeiting efforts. This plotline removes the film from the plethora of other Holocaust movies. The story is not about the warfare, or even the victims of the Nazis, but instead is about the politics of money and the German efforts to resist bankruptcy. Ruzowitzky avoids the cheap tension and horrible imagery of many war films by using a very benign soundtrack and bland, though very depressing backdrops. This viewpoint helps to show how multifaceted warfare and is one of the main intriguing aspects of the film.
Ruzowitzky’s film also differs from typical Holocaust films by creating a new type of Nazi official. The horror and cruelty is still present in the character of Herzog, but he is just as deep and as round of a character as Sally or the other Jewish prisoners. We see Sally and the other prisoners struggling to survive, but we see that life and survival is not a cakewalk for Herzog and the other Nazi’s either. Ruzowitzky offers us insight into the kind of mindset Herzog has and as he says it best “Ultimately your survival is what it’s all about.”
“The Counterfeiters” is a film capable of turning a counterfeiter into a hero, a Nazi into a frightened human being worth of empathy, and World War II into a game of strategic banking. That is the beauty of this Austrian gem. It may not be the most exciting Holocaust film, but it is the first I have encountered to take a story of strength and survival and add an element of moral ambiguity which left me with more questions than answers by the final credits.
Movie: Die Falscher Director: Stefan Ruzowitzky Starring: Karl Markovics, August Diehl Year: 2007
With counterfeiters, the German film industry presents a rare realistic depiction of the Second World War with a script that presents a balanced story rather than straying towards a typical plain sighted Nazi bashing. Based on a book by Adolf Burger, Counterfeiters is a story about a group of Jewish prisoners in a Nazi death camp who are designated to assist the Germans in printing fake currency so as to enable them to crash the British economy. The brilliant soundtrack and cinematography are enhanced by the convincing work that much of the cast of the film present. The central idea of the film deals with the ever present turmoil of survival and idealism faced by every person that has witnessed war. While the eventual fate of both the characters is revealed early on in the film, the main question raised is as to how they get there. Salomon (played by Markovics) is a survivalist who wants to survive for as long as he possibly can under the control of the Nazi officers, while Burger (Diehl) is the revolutionary idealist who would rather die fighting than assist the Nazi captors at any time. The choices and decisions made by the individuals in the movie are meant to be scrutinized by the viewer and either way ones loyalty ends up, it is hard to ignore the other.
Counterfeiters tells a true story all the while maintaining the climax. Apart from the two central Protaonistic characters, there are various side characters that are likeable and their fates become a concern for the viewer as the story goes on. The dramatic depth is conveyed beautifully with the feeling of ambiguity and tension for the characters. The Nazis are given a fair portrayal as parts of a functioning machinery rather than being completely demonized.
Counterfeiters attempts to earn the viewers respect through endeavor and genuine spirit rather than sympathy or pity. A realistic and accurate depiction of the Holocaust days, I see it as a moderate recommendation for anyone that enjoys espionage and war films or anything in between.
Out of all of the Holocaust themed movies I have seen, The Counterfeiters is different from them all. This movie shows that there counterfeit money was being made during the Holocaust to save Germany because it was bankrupt. I had no idea that this operation was occurring. This operation led to the discovering of two heroes in this movie-1) Soloman Sorowitsch and 2) Adolf Burger. At first Sally appears to be the hero because when he arrives at Mautchenhausen he saves the operation because he is a professional criminal at counterfeiting. If Sally has an internal conflict with making the counterfeit for the enemy, it is not directly expressed in the movie. However, Burger is the real hero. His decision to not produce counterfeit delayed the production of it, which kept the Nazis from having enough money to take over the British government. One would think that since Burger wrote the book on which the movie is based he would be in the spotlight, but that is not the case. I feel that the depiction of Burger in this form is probably close to him in person. He is one who sticks to his morals and beliefs, even if it means certain death, and does not like being in the spotlight.
ReplyDeleteAnother aspect that was different about this movie was that it showed the break-down of the Nazis. In most Holocaust movies, the Nazis are depicted as men who have a one-track mind and only act cruel; they seem to have no feelings. Then all of a sudden they are defeated and gone. However, in The Counterfeiters the Nazis are shown having a desperate side at the end of the war and that they will stoop to anything to stay alive, even asking a criminal to make fake passports so he and his family can escape death for the cruel acts he had committed. Because this movie has such a different take on the Holocaust with very little murder and beating, rather a history lesson that’s entertaining, I feel everyone should see this Oscar-winning film.
When you think of a Holocaust movie, the movie Schlinder’s list comes to mind, along with scenes of death and horror. The Counterfeiters is not like that at all, it does not contain that same amount of suspense that other Holocaust movies do. In the Counterfeiters the audience only saw someone getting shot twice, the friend who got shot in the head and the random man in the shower that did not want to get up. In other Holocaust movies, like Escape from Sobibor, the director shows graphic scenes of Jews being shot and tortured. Without the numerous scenes of someone being shot, the audience does not feel the same amount of despair after the movie. The audience feels more of a sense of hope than of despair.
ReplyDeleteThe Counterfeiters gave the Jews a sense of hope. The Jews that had special talents were treated better than the others, they were given soft beds, weekends off, were beaten very, very rarely, got to shower and were rewarded with a ping pong table. The counterfeiting Jews were given hope and did not have to go searching for it. In most Holocaust movies, like Escape from Sobibor all hope was stripped from the Jews. Jews were not given hope, it was stolen from them. In one scene thirteen Jews had to pick thirteen others to die with them or fifteen would be chosen to die with them by the Nazis. The Jews that were not chosen were told to watch and if they looked away or closed their eyes then they would also die along with the twenty-six already dying. In that movie the Jews had no hope; they had to rely on one another but were forced to kill each other. The Nazi’s gave them no reward or hope, not even false hope. The Jews had to find their own hope and most of them lost it completely. The Counterfeiters were a very special case during that time. The director did a good job at taking most of the suspense out of the movie. The director also did a good job at not creating another blood bath Holocaust movie, but one with hope and different forms of heroes.
This holocaust film is one of a kind. Unlike nearly all of the other films on the holocaust, this one avoids the typical suspense and tension that is created from these terrifying situations. The director, Stefan Ruzowitzky, chose to start the film by revealing its ultimate happy ending. I believe that he chose to start the film in such a way that would relieve the audience from the stress and tension that is built up from the actions leading up to his happy ending. This also serves as an attention getter for the audience because it brings about a sudden interest in how he survived such a horrifying event. This film also depicts the holocaust in an original way. The majority of these types of films depict the pure horror that took place, but “The Counterfeiters” sheds a little bit of light on this grim happening. This film is characterized as a drama because it depicts people under pressure and tension under high stakes in a concentration camp. The jews depicted in this particular concentration camp were living in luxury. They were given soft beds, food, and a weekly shower. A few of those in the concentration camps were happy to have these luxuries, but at the same time they were still dead men. They knew once their work was done that the Nazi’s would kill them. Even the Nazi’s in this film are shown as people just like those in the concentration camps rather than pure evil, unbreakable, and cruel men. They did not want to be there anymore than those being kept as prisoners. This is revealed when one of the Nazi’s makes a deal with the main character, Salomon, to forge him fake passports to get him and his family out of there. This is a great film that allows you to learn from the experience without actually going through it yourself.
ReplyDeleteWho knew that the Nazi were making Jews counterfeit money for them? They were making them work for them while they killed their friends and families. The Nazi’s sicken me. The most sickening part in the movie to me was when the SS officer allowed Sorowitsch to come to his home. While there the officer paraded him about his house and introduced him to his children. He pretended to be friends with Sorowitsch in front of his family. How can a man raise decent, morale children who has been responsible for the deaths and holocaust of so many people?
ReplyDeleteAnother scene that I like was when Burger and Sorowitsch were playing table tennis. Until that moment Sorowitsch had never been public about his morals. Sorowowitsch might have been a criminal but he would have never done the things the Nazi’s did. It’s ironic that Sorowitsch was given a green triangle making his as a criminal. Was he killing thousands of hundreds of people, was he murdering innocent women children and men. Who is the real criminal here? It was funny to see Burger acknowledge the fact that Sorowitsch didn’t want people to see that he has feelings. Even when the boy that Sorowitsch is very close to is murdered we do not see Sorowitsch cry. We hear a deafening sound similar to a grenade exploding right next to our ear, which was a good trick on the part of the director.
The whole point of Holocaust films are to make people remember. To never forget the past. The Holocaust happened not at the hands of insane genocidal aliens but by normal men with families. We should never forget these horrible acts so that something like the Holocaust never happens again.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe Counterfeiters is definitely a different view on the holocaust. I am used to movies making a clear distinction between who was good and who was evil, but this movie blurs the lines a bit. Obviously the Nazi’s are bad, but unlike most holocaust movies, some of them are not evil. These men were normal people doing their job, following orders, they had families, and some of them were just trying to survive. It still does not excuse all of the horrible things they did to the Jews. Even though the main character was a criminal, we were still pushing for him to survive, to overcome these horrible things. When the special group of Jew’s was formed to make counterfeit money, they treated them well. The Nazi’s gave the prisoners soft, nice beds they gave them food to keep them healthy, even though just beyond the walls there were other Jews being starved and worked to death. One man had found the passports of his children and therefore believed he had no more reason to live, and the doctor told him he just needed to survive until the war was over. The second the war was over for them the man killed himself, because although he survived, he had no one to survive it for. Burger was the “hero” of the group. He stopped the Nazi’s counterfeit money from being produced. He put everyone’s life on the line every time he would destroy the gelatins, but he knew what the Nazi’s was doing was wrong, so he knew he had a duty to stop it. He did not end up stopping the Nazi’s completely, but he did slow them down greatly. Burger was the character who although he wanted to survive as much as everyone else, he was willing to die for the right thing.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis film is well organized and clever. Making a movie about the holocaust is risky because people in Austria and around the world are still very sensitive. The first scene in the movie is shot at Monte Carlo. The ocean looks refreshing the buildings are classy and the lights are breathtaking. All of these things combined made the opening scene truly exquisite. When Salomon walks into the hotel and opens up the briefcase full of money, it made me think it was going to be a James Bond type of film. Salomon had been living in luxury most of his life and was one of the most famous counterfeiters. After he got arrested the only thing that was keeping him alive was his unique ability to counterfeit. Salomon was put with other Jews that possessed special talents and were treated better. They had some days off and even a hot shower every now and then. What makes this film stand out from is that it does not thrive on being viewed as a thriller. Stefan knew that people in Austria would not want to see a thriller about the Holocaust. One skillfully thing Stefan did was whenever someone got shot, it was very fast. The scene of the person getting shot did not last over 15 seconds and there was not music playing beforehand to build the suspense up. He knew making a film about the Jews and Holocaust would already hit a soft spot in the audience’s hearts; it was good Stefan made the killing scenes as simple as he could. My favorite thing about this film as I watched it was it really forced me to care about what was happening. Throughout this whole movie, Salomon was under pressure. As he was told to do counterfeit in a specific time, I felt my heart racing just as fast as Salomon’s was. The audience began to care about Salomon and wanted to see him survive and make it out of prison. It was good seeing this film because I learned about an experience without actually going through it. It made me realize sometimes we forget how good we have it now. The film not only started with the Mote Carlo scene, but it also ended with it. This was just another clever thing Stefan did. The movie starts off on a positive note and ends on one too. Instead of showing a final fight scene or Salomon in prison, it shows Monte Carlo, which could symbolize happiness.
ReplyDeleteI have seen my fair share of holocaust films, especially as the subject is fairly common in American cinema. I anticipated that “The Counterfeiters” would be more of the same; gruesome imagery, gray landscapes, and a statement on the cruelty of man. I was surprised to find that all of my expectations of this film were, thankfully, off the mark. “The Counterfeiters” does make a statement on the cruelty of the Holocaust but does so without the gut-wrenching images of depravity that many Hollywood films seem to emphasize. This film presented the Holocaust and the Nazi regime in a way rarely utilized in cinema and thus, created a fresh and dynamic story with common subject matter and leaves you wondering if these characters are as bad as you first believed.
ReplyDeleteRuzowitzky shows us the concentration camps from the inside, as his protagonist is arrested and processed into the Nazi prisons. However, instead of leaving the story to run among the squalor and filth of the typical camps, we see the main character Sally taken to live in relative comfort in exchange for supervising the Nazi counterfeiting efforts. This plotline removes the film from the plethora of other Holocaust movies. The story is not about the warfare, or even the victims of the Nazis, but instead is about the politics of money and the German efforts to resist bankruptcy. Ruzowitzky avoids the cheap tension and horrible imagery of many war films by using a very benign soundtrack and bland, though very depressing backdrops. This viewpoint helps to show how multifaceted warfare and is one of the main intriguing aspects of the film.
Ruzowitzky’s film also differs from typical Holocaust films by creating a new type of Nazi official. The horror and cruelty is still present in the character of Herzog, but he is just as deep and as round of a character as Sally or the other Jewish prisoners. We see Sally and the other prisoners struggling to survive, but we see that life and survival is not a cakewalk for Herzog and the other Nazi’s either. Ruzowitzky offers us insight into the kind of mindset Herzog has and as he says it best “Ultimately your survival is what it’s all about.”
“The Counterfeiters” is a film capable of turning a counterfeiter into a hero, a Nazi into a frightened human being worth of empathy, and World War II into a game of strategic banking. That is the beauty of this Austrian gem. It may not be the most exciting Holocaust film, but it is the first I have encountered to take a story of strength and survival and add an element of moral ambiguity which left me with more questions than answers by the final credits.
Counterfeiters
ReplyDeleteMovie: Die Falscher
Director: Stefan Ruzowitzky
Starring: Karl Markovics, August Diehl
Year: 2007
With counterfeiters, the German film industry presents a rare realistic depiction of the Second World War with a script that presents a balanced story rather than straying towards a typical plain sighted Nazi bashing. Based on a book by Adolf Burger, Counterfeiters is a story about a group of Jewish prisoners in a Nazi death camp who are designated to assist the Germans in printing fake currency so as to enable them to crash the British economy. The brilliant soundtrack and cinematography are enhanced by the convincing work that much of the cast of the film present.
The central idea of the film deals with the ever present turmoil of survival and idealism faced by every person that has witnessed war. While the eventual fate of both the characters is revealed early on in the film, the main question raised is as to how they get there. Salomon (played by Markovics) is a survivalist who wants to survive for as long as he possibly can under the control of the Nazi officers, while Burger (Diehl) is the revolutionary idealist who would rather die fighting than assist the Nazi captors at any time. The choices and decisions made by the individuals in the movie are meant to be scrutinized by the viewer and either way ones loyalty ends up, it is hard to ignore the other.
Counterfeiters tells a true story all the while maintaining the climax. Apart from the two central Protaonistic characters, there are various side characters that are likeable and their fates become a concern for the viewer as the story goes on. The dramatic depth is conveyed beautifully with the feeling of ambiguity and tension for the characters. The Nazis are given a fair portrayal as parts of a functioning machinery rather than being completely demonized.
Counterfeiters attempts to earn the viewers respect through endeavor and genuine spirit rather than sympathy or pity. A realistic and accurate depiction of the Holocaust days, I see it as a moderate recommendation for anyone that enjoys espionage and war films or anything in between.