Sunday, May 23, 2010

Posts on City of God

Please post them here . . .

6 comments:

  1. When watching the film City of God, directed by Meirelles and Katia Lund, it was hard to keep in mind that the events taking place were based on a true story. My mind wanted to think back to what I previously knew about Rio de Janeiro, all the tourist type things, and then think that what I was watching in the film was fiction. It felt as if I was watching some action film with a grotesque amount of violence. It’s hard to remember that there are “different worlds” outside of the norm.

    Perhaps the best quality of the film was the fact that the audience was able to see this “different world” through the documentary style filming, meshing of story lines, and incredible acting. It is hard to imagine that the majority of the cast was made up of individuals who actually live in slums. Meirelles actually comments in an interview:
    When I decided to do the film, I wanted to do it with the same feeling as the book, this “inside” feeling. I knew I couldn’t get this feeling with professionals. And I wanted to use the expertise from the people inside the slums for the film. Whenever I gave them the script, instead of giving them the dialogue, I’d tell them what the intentions of the sequences were and let them improvise. (The Hollywood Interview)
    And this is what makes the film such a success. Even though most of the individuals who end up watching this film have no first hand experience, or any experience that even comes close to matching the events that take place, they are still able to feel that “inside” feeling, after the initial shock of all the violence sets in anyways. Of coarse this feeling is also powered by the style of filming and the great editing of the shots.

    If the cast had been made up of professional actors I do not believe that the audience would have been able to feel the same passion behind the acting. The scene where we see that it was Li’l Dice who had shot all the people in the hotel had to be the most emotional scene in the whole film. And maybe that idea was also another reason the film felt at first to be an action film instead of based on real events. The fact that, for the most part, the individuals engaging in the violence and helping to deal drugs were kids; some not even 10 years of age yet. The actual kids who took on these roles were phenomenal, especially for not being professional actors.

    This was truly a great film. It is important that we get a wake up call every once in awhile from what “know” and what better way to do so than through art.

    ReplyDelete
  2. City of God is 130 minutes of extraordinary film making combined with a remarkable screenplay that come together to create one of the best foreign films I have ever seen. Fernando Meirelles and Katia Lund do an amazing job of immersing you in the slum called City of God. One of the most astounding things about this film is the fact that all but one of the actors in the movie are actual residents of favelas, or slums, such as the City of God and Vidigal. The acting done by these natives is so realistic because they are just being themselves. The fact that the actors are experts on the topic pooled with the director’s idea to let them improvise creates a profoundly realistic experience for the viewer.

    Not only is the screenplay and the acting perfect but the editing is also breathtaking. The directors use techniques I have never seen before. One of the most eye-catching scenes is the story of the apartment. It is a 5 minute scene full of the cleanest fading in and out I have ever witnessed. Also, at the beginning of the movie, there is a scene of many people cooking chickens outside. It is made up of probably hundreds of small shots edited together, each clip with its own diagetic sound that creates an incredible start to the movie.

    It is extremely hard, if not impossible to find something bad to say about this film. The acting, screenplay, and editing are beautiful and they completely juxtapose the real brutal plot of the film. Although there is extreme violence it is not exaggerated and everything is filmed in such a documentary style that it seems all too real. City of God is a film that may not be for the faint of heart, but is a miraculous movie that I wouldn’t mind watching time and time again.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Many crime films center themselves around a “rise to power”. The first two parts of Francis Fro Coppola’s “Godfather” trilogy deal with two generations of a Sicilian-American crime family and how they each acquired their respective power and influence. Martin Scorsese’s “Goodfellas” follows Henry Hill from adolescence through mid-Adulthood, as he makes his way from low-level underling to a considerable force to be reckoned with in the Tandino Family criminal element. However, none of these films, excellent as they are, can quite compare with the brutality and pathos that “City of God” is rife with.
    In this case, the “rise to power” in question is that of Dandhino, and how he decidedly, petty crime by petty crime, becomes the most feared and respected criminal in the titular Brazilian slum, earning the moniker “Ze Pequeno” (or “Li’l Dice”). His path, unlike Henry Hill’s was not laid out for him by superiors in the criminal world that wanted his rise to be as cushy and comfortable as possible. Li’l Dice had to claw his way to the top, tooth and nail, fighting just to stay alive even as he was murdering and robbing person after innocent person. Not only physical conflicts, but social and economic conditions were besetting him on all sides.
    The reason this distinction is so important is that we, as Americans, tend to romanticize the criminal in our art and literature. And, while there is nothing inherently wrong with this tendency, it is important to also understand the reality of such characters. Yes, a criminal can have good intentions and may even act in a philanthropic manner, as we see in this film briefly. But, what “City of God” tells us, more than anything, is that the complexities of a mind that has developed while it has plotted and carried out mass murder amongst a plethora of human offenses, are too mysterious to fully understand. And, these decisions are not without consequence.
    -Jon Becraft

    ReplyDelete
  4. From the opening scene of City of God to the ending, I was speechless. The first thing the audience saw was a chicken that thought it was going to die so inn escaped. This was the only time during the movie I laughed. People are chasing the chicken and all of a sudden Rocket is in the middle of the street with guns aimed at him. I really liked how this shot froze and circled around him. After this it shot back to him playing soccer in a field and the City of God story begins. The title makes this movie sound uplifting and promising. City of God, this could not possibly be about a young kid shooting random people at a hotel. Well it is more then that. It is about multiple kids shooting people. This movie showed children in Rio de Janeiro and the everyday struggles they endured. The director does not focus on poverty, crime and the tragedies the children had to go through. Rather he focuses on the cruel reality that everyone living there had to go through in order to survive. It shocked me that men would hand guns to children. So many children smoked in this film that for a second it crossed my mind that marijuana was legal at that time. The reason law enforcement officers did not want to get involved in stopping it is because the gangs were too dangerous. In their eyes, maybe it was not worth getting shot over. One thing that I noticed was that in sunlight there were a lot of bright colors. This may symbolize brightness for the future. The beach seemed to be one of the only scenes in the movie that was not dark. The dance was skillfully done. It showed everyone dancing and how the adolescents had fun. The ending was full of violence. At some times the audience did not know who was killing who, or for what reason. The only real hope for the people living there was to leave and get out while they still could. The movie really showed a glimpse of people that fight to be on top and people who fight to escape. The movie started in blood and it ended in blood. I was speechless while the credits were rolling, I was lost for words

    ReplyDelete
  5. This film was definitely one of the best films shown in class. Even though it was filled with death and destruction, the film itself was fantastic. The editing alone is worth at least two out of the five gold stars I would give this movie. Within the first sequence the editing is pure magic. Countless shots one right after another show off the skill the editors have. The screenplay was excellent the way the story constantly went back in time, and yet the audience never seemed to get confused. The voiceover of the main character helped keep the story fluid and understandable. I found it interesting that the actors were not professional and that the script wasn’t as much as a script as it was improve. Overall I think the thing that captured my attention the most and kept me interested, were the images. There are certain images that I will always remember this for. The first one is the image of the teenagers robbing the truck and the other people in the town running to take the gas tanks, and the second is the little boy shooting the innocent people in the motel. The image that will stick out in my head for a long time and is the image that shook me the most in the story is when the little boy who has been shot in the foot is screaming and crying because the other little boy had a gun pointed to his face. Not only does the image play in my head, but the sound of the little boy’s crying; how absolutely terrified this boy was. This movie was one of my favorites in the class, but I am not sure I could watch it again. As a film it was fantastic, but the violence was just a little too much for me, and I don’t think I could watch it again.

    ReplyDelete
  6. “City of God” was a beautiful film but it was hard to watch at times. The movie is particularly notable for its brutality and the richness of the acting. The editing catches the claustrophobic and frantic atmosphere of life in the slums and masterfully weaves the stories of several interesting characters.

    In the City of God, gang violence and drugs claim the lives and livelihoods of many children and teens. The psychopathic Lil Dice grows into Lil Ze and becomes even more violent. The film follows the rise and fall of Lil Ze contrasting with the struggle for survival of the few innocent characters. Violence is prevalent and the brutality of the child gangsters is emotionally disturbing. Despite being mostly amateurs, the cast manages to form personas of hedonism and naivety that work perfectly in the story. The most vivid scene where this combination is realized is the shooting and murder of two of The Runts. Lil Ze offers the choice of being shot in the hand or the foot and then forces another child to kill one of the two hostages. The blood, brutality, and the sound of a child’s cries make that particular scene a gut wrenching example of how the film was a no holds barred portrait of slum life in Rio.

    From a technical aspect, “City of God” is masterfully edited. The city of Rio come alive with energy and vitality through spastic montage sequences. Also, the director manages to provide plot twist but simple changing the way the audience is present an image. The robbery at the hospital is the most obvious example, when we are first presented the image of the victims without the connection of Lil Dice’s rampage to connect to the story. This denial of fact is what leaves the audience engaged with the story and hungry to see it play out.

    ReplyDelete